Carol’s Cookie Kitchen

Carol’s Cookie KitchenCarol’s Cookie KitchenCarol’s Cookie Kitchen

Carol’s Cookie Kitchen

Carol’s Cookie KitchenCarol’s Cookie KitchenCarol’s Cookie Kitchen
  • Home
  • About us
  • Cookie list and pricing
  • More
    • Home
    • About us
    • Cookie list and pricing

  • Home
  • About us
  • Cookie list and pricing

Menu / Price List

Specialty

*Minimum order of 2 dozen per cookie type

Chocolate Chip

$9.00/ dozen

Our Chocolate Chip Cookies are a hit at any event. They are soft and chewy made with creamy Irish butter and a special addition of vanilla pudding. They are perfect for pairing with a cup of coffee or a nice cold glass of milk!

Brownie Bites

$10.00 / dozen

Our Brownie Bites are oh so fudgy and rich, containing mini chocolate chips! But that’s not all, they are also topped with our buttery vanilla buttercream icing!

Our iced sugar cookie with pictured Easter sprinkles!! 🐰 🥚 🐥

Iced Sugar Cookie/ Easter edition

$10.00 / dozen

Our Iced Sugar Cookies are a classic favorite. These soft and chewy cookies are iced with vanilla buttercream and topped with sprinkles! A variety of other toppings may be available for holidays or special occasions!

easter sprinkles pictured 🐰🐥🥚

M n M Easter edition

$10.00 / dozen

Our M n M Cookies are made with the same special chocolate chip cookie recipe. M n M colors may vary according to holiday or special occasion. 

Peppermint Iced Sugar Cookie

$10 / dozen

Our yummy soft Iced Sugar Cookies with a touch of mint and topped with crushed candy canes! A refreshing winter treat! 

Peanut butter Kiss

$10 / dozen

This one is a classic treat loved year-round, featuring a soft, chewy peanut butter cookie topped with a rich, chocolate kiss. A nostalgic favorite that melts in your mouth with every bite. Whether for holidays, special occasions, or everyday indulgence, it is simply a delight!


Premium

Minimum order of 2 dozen per cookie type

Linzer

$12.00 / dozen

Our Linzers are for those who love anything raspberry!  The seedless raspberry preserves are sandwiched between 2 melt in your mouth cookies and covered with a generous dusting of powdered sugar!

Reese’s Bites

$12.00 / dozen

Our Reese’s Bites have always been a family favorite around the Holidays! With our yummy sugar cookie dough filled with a mini peanut butter cup.  You’re welcome 😊

Almond Thumbprints

$12.00 / dozen

Our Almond Thumbprints are another crowd favorite at any event. These ones are rolled in sprinkles and have an almond buttercream icing!

If there is a special flavor you are looking for feel free to make a suggestion and we’ll see what we can do 😉

Walnut Fudge Thumbprints

$12.00 / dozen

Our Walnut Fudge Thumbprints are rolled in walnuts and topped with a generous amount of fudgy buttercream!!!!

Buckeyes

$12.00 / dozen

Our Buckeyes  have always been a favorite for family and friends. The rich creamy flavor comes from using quality peanut butter and creamy Irish butter. Always one of the first to disappear at any event! 

Mini Lady Locks

$12 / dozen

Our Lady locks are a delicate pastry filled with a rich, creamy vanilla filling and dusted with powdered sugar. An irresistible treat!


Signature

Minimum order of 2 dozen per cookie type

Gingerbread Salted Caramel Thumbprints /seasonal

$15.00 / dozen

Our Premium Thumbprint with an added flair!

Featuring homemade salted caramel and a gingerbread buttercream icing!!

Candy Cane Thumbprint /seasonal

$15.00 / dozen

Our Premium Thumbprint with an added flair!

Featuring buttercream icing with a touch of mint topped with crushed candy canes!!

Salted Caramel

$15/dozen

Our Premium Thumbprint with an added flair!

Featuring buttercream icing with a touch of salted caramel and topped with a generous drizzle of our homemade salted caramel!!

With your choice of sprinkles (Jimmies) or walnuts!

White Chocolate Raspberry Thumbprint

$15.00 / dozen

A rich, buttery cookie with a soft center and crisp edges. Each cookie is carefully indented and filled with a  dollop of tangy raspberry preserves, adding a burst of fruity sweetness that perfectly balances the smooth, decadent white chocolate buttercream and drizzled with more raspberry yumminess!! These elegant cookies are a delightful treat for any occasion!

Orange Creamsicle Thumbprint

$15 / dozen

If you’re looking for a taste of summer then you should try this addition to the menu!!  🍊  🍦   
An Orange thumbprint with an orange buttercream and topped with a white chocolate drizzle!! Yum 😋 

Strawberry Pretzel Salad Thumbprint

$15/dozen

This creation is a yummy representation of the Jello pretzel salad in a cookie! 🍓🥨. The pretzel cookie is topped with a homemade strawberry jam, our vanilla buttercream mixed with a strawberry jello buttercream then topped with more jam and crushed pretzels!!  This will be a seasonal selection that will be around for spring and summer 🍓🥨

enjoy!!!!

Your suggestion

$15/dozen

We would like to know what flavors you want to taste in one of our Premium Thumbprints. 

If you have a suggestion just send us a text and we’ll try it out! Who knows, it may become a new addition to our menu!!!! ❤️


Cookies and Cream Thumbprint

$15.00 / dozen

A soft, buttery thumbprint cookie rolled in Oreo crumbs and sprinkles, then topped with rich cookies and cream icing and a generous sprinkle of crumbled Oreos for the perfect crunchy finish. A dreamy treat for any cookies and cream lover

*MINIMUM ORDER OF 2 DOZEN PER COOKIE TYPE

Copyright © 2025 Carol’s Cookie Kitchen - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept